Home / Articles / Working with an agency

When not to advertise on Reddit

By the Team of Monkeys Reddit ads team | | 3 min read

Team of Monkeys illustration for the article: When not to advertise on Reddit

It may seem strange for a company that runs Reddit campaigns to publish an article about not running them. We think it is the most useful thing we can write. Reddit is excellent for many businesses and wrong for some, and finding out which you are after the money is gone is the expensive way to learn.

Seven signs Reddit is the wrong channel

1. Your customers are not there

Reddit's audience is large but not universal. It leans toward English speakers, toward North America and Western Europe, and toward people comfortable online. If you sell mainly to an audience that does not use Reddit, or in a language and market where it is small, the ads have nobody to reach.

2. No community discusses your category

Reddit advertising depends on community targeting. If a search of the platform shows no active discussions about your type of product, the foundation is missing.

3. Your product has unresolved problems

If customers are already complaining about quality, billing or support, advertising to a platform built for candid discussion will amplify it. Fix the problem first. Advertise second.

4. The offer depends on hype

Redditors check claims. Offers built on exaggeration, pressure or fine print fare badly, and loudly.

5. You need local foot traffic

A restaurant, a salon or a neighbourhood shop needs people within a few kilometres. Local search and maps do that job far better.

6. You cannot measure what happens after the click

Without conversion tracking and a way to connect ads to sales, you will never know whether the campaign worked. Sort that out before advertising anywhere.

7. You need results this week

Reddit campaigns need a few weeks to learn. If the business needs sales in the next seven days to survive, a slower-building channel is not the answer.

Signs that Reddit is a good fit

For balance, the opposite list:

How to check for yourself in an hour

  1. Search Reddit for your category and your competitors. Are there recent, active threads?
  2. Search for your own brand. What do people already say?
  3. List the communities where your buyers might be. Are they large and active enough?
  4. Read the top posts in those communities. Could your product be mentioned there without embarrassment?
  5. Check that your site can track conversions.

If most answers are encouraging, a test is worth it. If most are not, your money has better uses.

The grey area

Many products fall somewhere in between. The audience exists but is small, or the product is good but hard to explain. In those cases a tightly limited test, with clear stop rules, is the honest way to find out. We describe how to structure one in our article on budgets and testing.

Why we say no

Team of Monkeys earns 25% of ad spend. In the short term, we would earn more by saying yes to everyone. We do not, for a simple reason: our goal is repeat business. A client who spends money on a campaign that was never going to work will not return, and will be right not to.

So the first conversation is an assessment, and it costs nothing. We look at your product, your market and what Reddit already says about you.

If we do not think your product will succeed on Reddit, we will tell you before you spend any money. If we think it will, we will tell you why, and what we would do.

When we do take a campaign on, we expect it to perform. The campaigns we run deliver click-through and conversion rates that lead the industry, across multiple industries, and part of the reason is that we only run the ones that should be run. Saying no to the wrong campaigns is how we keep clients consistently happy with the right ones.

If you would like that assessment, book a call. The worst outcome is that you save your budget.

Common questions

What kinds of businesses should avoid Reddit ads?

Purely local businesses, products with unresolved reputation problems, offers that rely on hype, and anyone whose customers are simply not on the platform.

What if my product has mixed reviews on Reddit?

Mixed is normal. Read the criticism carefully. If it points to something you have fixed, say so in your campaign. If it points to something still broken, fix it before advertising.

Want to know if Reddit will work for your product?

Team of Monkeys is a Reddit advertising agency that plans, writes, launches and manages campaigns with click-through and conversion rates that lead the industry, across many industries. If we do not think your product will succeed on Reddit, we will tell you before you spend any money. Our goal is repeat business, and we only earn that when you are consistently happy with the results. See our simple pricing or book a 30 minute call.

Keep reading

Advertise on Reddit with a team that tells you the truth

Bring what you sell and what you want to spend. We will tell you plainly whether Reddit is worth your money, and how we would run it.

Book A Call See How We Advertise On Reddit